1. Headline earnings
Total | Continuing operations | Discontinued operations | |||||
30 November 2021 Unaudited R'000 |
30 November 2020 Unaudited R'000 |
30 November 2021 Unaudited R'000 |
30 November 2020 Unaudited R'000 |
30 November 2021 Unaudited R'000 |
30 November 2020 Unaudited R'000 |
Profit attributable to equity holders of the parent | 531 451 | 440 090 | 530 440 | 412 601 | 1 011 | 27 489 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Net profit on disposal of property, plant and equipment | (244) | (672) | (244) | (332) | — | (340) | |
Net (profit)/loss on disposal of intangible assets | (270) | 1 435 | (270) | 1 435 | — | — | |
Impairment/(impairment reversal) of property, plant and equipment | 1 887 | (2 284) | 1 887 | — | — | (2 284) | |
Foreign currency translation reserve recycled to profit or loss | — | (52 538) | — | (52 538) | — | — | |
Net profit on sale of associates | — | (24 965) | — | (24 965) | — | — | |
Headline earnings | 532 824 | 361 066 | 531 813 | 336 201 | 1 011 | 24 865 | |
Headline earnings per share | 60.86 | 40.96 | 60.74 | 38.14 | 0.12 | 2.82 |
2. Share performance
Total | |||||
30 November 2021 Unaudited R'000 |
30 November 2020 Unaudited R'000 |
30 November 2021 Unaudited R'000 |
30 November 2020 Unaudited R'000 |
||
Headline earnings per share | Attributable earnings |
Attributable earnings |
Cents per share |
Cents per share |
|
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Basic | 532 824 | 361 066 | 60.86 | 40.96 | |
Diluted | 532 824 | 361 066 | 58.76 | 39.25 | |
Core | 548 831 | 376 433 | 62.69 | 42.70 | |
Earnings attributable to ordinary equity holders | |||||
Basic | 531 451 | 440 090 | 60.71 | 49.92 | |
Diluted | 531 451 | 440 090 | 58.61 | 47.85 | |
Weighted average number of shares | |||||
Weighted average number of ordinary shares | 875 496 083 | 881 556 907 | |||
Adjusted for forfeitable shares | 31 243 614 | 38 295 663 | |||
Weighted average number of ordinary shares for diluted earnings | 906 739 697 | 919 852 570 | |||
Number of shares in issue | 913 655 873 | 913 655 873 | |||
Number of shares in issue excluding treasury shares | 876 453 719 | 874 781 449 | |||
Reconciliation between profit and core headline earnings for the period: | |||||
Profit for the period attributable to equity holders of the parent | 531 451 | 440 090 | |||
Amortisation on intangible assets raised through business combinations net of tax and net of non-controlling interest | 16 007 | 15 367 | |||
Core profit for the period | 547 458 | 455 457 | |||
Headline earnings adjustments | 1 373 | (79 024) | |||
Core headline earnings | 548 831 | 376 433 | |||
Core headline earnings per share (cents) | 62.69 | 42.70 |
Continuing operations | |||||
30 November 2021 Unaudited R'000 |
30 November 2020 Unaudited R'000 |
30 November 2021 Unaudited R'000 |
30 November 2020 Unaudited R'000 |
||
Headline earnings per share | Attributable earnings |
Attributable earnings |
Cents per share |
Cents per share |
|
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Basic | 531 813 | 336 201 | 60.74 | 38.14 | |
Diluted | 531 813 | 336 201 | 58.65 | 36.55 | |
Core | 547 820 | 351 568 | 62.57 | 39.88 | |
Earnings attributable to ordinary equity holders | |||||
Basic | 530 440 | 412 601 | 60.59 | 46.80 | |
Diluted | 530 440 | 412 601 | 58.50 | 44.86 | |
Weighted average number of shares | |||||
Weighted average number of ordinary shares | 875 496 083 | 881 556 907 | |||
Adjusted for forfeitable shares | 31 243 614 | 38 295 663 | |||
Weighted average number of ordinary shares for diluted earnings | 906 739 697 | 919 852 570 | |||
Number of shares in issue | 913 655 873 | 913 655 873 | |||
Number of shares in issue excluding treasury shares | 876 453 719 | 874 781 449 | |||
Reconciliation between profit and core headline earnings for the period: | |||||
Profit for the period attributable to equity holders of the parent | 530 440 | 412 601 | |||
Amortisation on intangible assets raised through business combinations net of tax and net of non-controlling interest | 16 007 | 15 367 | |||
Core profit for the period | 546 447 | 427 968 | |||
Headline earnings adjustments | 1 373 | (76 400) | |||
Core headline earnings | 547 820 | 351 568 | |||
Core headline earnings per share (cents) | 62.57 | 39.88 |
Discontinued operations | |||||
30 November 2021 Unaudited R'000 |
30 November 2020 Unaudited R'000 |
30 November 2021 Unaudited R'000 |
30 November 2020 Unaudited R'000 |
||
Headline earnings per share | Attributable earnings |
Attributable earnings |
Cents per share |
Cents per share |
|
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Basic | 1 011 | 24 865 | 0.12 | 2.82 | |
Diluted | 1 011 | 24 865 | 0.11 | 2.70 | |
Core | 1 011 | 24 865 | 0.12 | 2.82 | |
Earnings attributable to ordinary equity holders | |||||
Basic | 1 011 | 27 489 | 0.12 | 3.12 | |
Diluted | 1 011 | 27 489 | 0.11 | 2.99 | |
Weighted average number of shares | |||||
Weighted average number of ordinary shares | 875 496 083 | 881 556 907 | |||
Adjusted for forfeitable shares | 31 243 614 | 38 295 663 | |||
Weighted average number of ordinary shares for diluted earnings | 906 739 697 | 919 852 570 | |||
Number of shares in issue | 913 655 873 | 913 655 873 | |||
Number of shares in issue excluding treasury shares | 876 453 719 | 874 781 449 | |||
Reconciliation between profit and core headline earnings for the period: | |||||
Profit for the period attributable to equity holders of the parent | 1 011 | 27 489 | |||
Amortisation on intangible assets raised through business combinations net of tax and net of non-controlling interest | — | — | |||
Core profit for the period | 1 011 | 27 489 | |||
Headline earnings adjustments | — | (2 624) | |||
Core headline earnings | 1 011 | 24 865 | |||
Core headline earnings per share (cents) | 0.12 | 2.82 |
3. Segmental summary
Total | Africa | International | Solutions | Corporate | ||
Unaudited R'000 |
Distribution Unaudited R'000 |
Unaudited R'000 |
Unaudited R'000 |
Unaudited R'000 |
||
Total segment revenue | 12 617 920 | 12 326 227 | — | 126 460 | 165 233 | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Internal revenue | (3 505 046) | (3 339 262) | — | (551) | (165 233) | |
Revenue | 9 112 874 | 8 986 965 | — | 125 909 | — | |
Operating profit/(loss) before depreciation and amortisation | 902 499 | 941 935 | (876) | 7 584 | (46 144) | |
Profit/(loss) from continuing operations for the period attributable to equity holders of the parent | 530 440 | 578 271 | (796) | 18 430 | (65 465) | |
Profit for the period from discontinued operations attributable to equity holders of the parent | 1 011 | 1 011 | — | — | — | |
Profit/(loss) for the period attributable to equity holders of the parent | 531 451 | 579 282 | (796) | 18 430 | (65 465) | |
Amortisation on intangibles raised through business combinations net of tax and non-controlling interest | 16 007 | 16 007 | — | — | — | |
Headline earnings adjustments net of non-controlling interest | 1 373 | 1 433 | — | (6) | (54) | |
Core headline earnings for the period attributable to equity holders of the parent | 548 831 | 596 722 | (796) | 18 424 | (65 519) |
Total | Africa | International | Solutions | Corporate | ||
Unaudited R'000 |
Distribution Unaudited R'000 |
Unaudited R'000 |
Unaudited R'000 |
Unaudited R'000 |
||
Total segment revenue | 13 667 036 | 13 489 243 | — | 91 740 | 86 053 | |
Internal revenue | (4 085 014) | (3 996 437) | — | (2 524) | (86 053) | |
Revenue | 9 582 022 | 9 492 806 | — | 89 216 | — | |
Operating profit/(loss) before depreciation and amortisation | 703 334 | 663 285 | 66 704 | 13 424 | (40 079) | |
Profit/(loss) from continuing operations for the period attributable to equity holders of the parent | 412 601 | 391 553 | 66 855 | 12 667 | (58 474) | |
Profit for the period from discontinued operations attributable to equity holders of the parent | 27 489 | 27 489 | — | — | — | |
Profit/(loss) for the period attributable to equity holders of the parent | 440 090 | 419 042 | 66 855 | 12 667 | (58 474) | |
Amortisation on intangibles raised through business combinations net of tax and non-controlling interest | 15 367 | 15 367 | — | — | — | |
Headline earnings adjustments net of non-controlling interest | (79 024) | (1 475) | (79 493) | — | 1 944 | |
Core headline earnings for the period attributable to equity holders of the parent | 376 433 | 432 934 | (12 638) | 12 667 | (56 530) |
4. Revenue
Total | Africa Distribution | Solutions | |||||
30 November 2021 Unaudited R'000 |
30 November 2020 Unaudited R'000 |
30 November 2021 Unaudited R'000 |
30 November 2020 Unaudited R'000 |
30 November 2021 Unaudited R'000 |
30 November 2020 Unaudited R'000 |
||
Revenue from contracts with customers | 8 627 886 | 9 365 787 | 8 501 977 | 9 276 571 | 125 909 | 89 216 | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Prepaid airtime, data and related revenue | 7 595 115 | 8 333 550 | 7 595 115 | 8 333 550 | — | — | |
Postpaid airtime, data and related revenue | 45 696 | 54 723 | 45 696 | 54 723 | — | — | |
Prepaid and postpaid SIM cards | 258 042 | 293 229 | 258 042 | 293 229 | — | — | |
Services | 200 132 | 174 365 | 74 223 | 85 149 | 125 909 | 89 216 | |
Electricity commission | 177 066 | 184 911 | 177 066 | 184 911 | — | — | |
Handsets, tablets and other devices | 154 966 | 186 271 | 154 966 | 186 271 | — | — | |
Other revenue | 196 869 | 138 738 | 196 869 | 138 738 | — | — | |
Subscription income share | 286 405 | — | 286 405 | — | — | — | |
Revenue | 8 914 291 | 9 365 787 | 8 788 382 | 9 276 571 | 125 909 | 89 216 | |
Finance revenue | 198 583 | 216 235 | 198 583 | 216 235 | — | — | |
Total revenue | 9 112 874 | 9 582 022 | 8 986 965 | 9 492 806 | 125 909 | 89 216 |
5. Discontinued operations
Accounting policy
A discontinued operation is a component of the entity that has been disposed of or is classified as held-for-sale and that represents a separate major line of business or geographical area of operations, is part of a single co-ordinated plan to dispose of such a line of business or area of operations, or is a subsidiary acquired exclusively with a view to resale. The results of discontinued operations are presented separately in the statement of comprehensive income.
Description
Closure of WiConnect
While management had implemented a turnaround strategy at WiConnect (a wholly owned subsidiary of the Group), which incorporated the strengthening of the retail management team, a refocus of product sales as well as negotiating additional rebates from the network operators and original equipment manufacturers, Covid-19 had a significant negative impact on the retail operations of WiConnect. These included increased costs of inventories as a result of a weaker rand, periods of non-trading as a result of the nationwide lockdown and consumers foregoing discretionary purchases. Given the uncertainty of the tenure of the pandemic and the resultant losses attributable thereto impacting on its financial feasibility, a decision was made on 11 May 2020 to cease the operations of the WiConnect retail stores.
Significant management judgement was applied in determining whether WiConnect is a discontinued operation by assessing whether it had effectively been ceased to be used or abandoned by 31 May 2020 and also whether it represented a separate major line of business or geographical area of operations or was part of a single plan to dispose of a separate major line of business or geographical area of operations. For further information regarding management's considerations in concluding that WiConnect was a discontinued operation, please refer to the information under Critical accounting judgements and assumptions.
Management believes that the above assessment is still applicable for the six-month period ended 30 November 2021. The costs incurred and revenues earned post the 31 May 2020 year-end have all been elements of the winding down of the WiConnect operations. Management has negotiated terms with substantially all landlords resulting in significant savings on lease liability costs that were accounted for as modifications to the lease terms. These modifications have been recorded in the "Profit from discontinued operation" line item within the condensed Group statement of comprehensive income. Management is in the process of collecting outstanding debt owed to WiConnect from its trade receivables and in settling trade and other sundry creditors.
Financial performance of discontinued operations
WiConnect six months ended 30 November 2021 Unaudited R'000 |
WiConnect six months ended 30 November 2020 Unaudited R'000 |
|||
Revenue and other incomes | 1 501 | 42 793 | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Expenses | (98) | (12 748) | ||
Profit before taxation | 1 403 | 30 045 | ||
Taxation | (392) | (2 556) | ||
Profit after taxation of discontinued operations | 1 011 | 27 489 | ||
Exchange differences on translation of discontinued operations | — | — | ||
Other comprehensive loss from discontinued operations | — | — | ||
Total comprehensive income from discontinued operations | 1 011 | 27 489 | ||
Profit for the period attributable to: | 1 011 | 27 489 | ||
Equity holders of the parent | 1 011 | 27 489 | ||
Non-controlling interest | — | — | ||
Total comprehensive income for the period attributable to: | 1 011 | 27 489 | ||
Equity holders of the parent | 1 011 | 27 489 | ||
Non-controlling interest | — | — | ||
Net cash inflow from ordinary activities | 150 | 10 099 | ||
Net cash outflow from investing activities | — | (1 981) | ||
Net increase in cash generated by the discontinued operations | 150 | 8 118 |
Critical accounting judgements and assumptions
WiConnect discontinued operations considerations
Paragraph 13 of IFRS 5 states that if a disposal group meets the discontinued operation criteria, the cash flows and results of the disposal group should be presented as discontinued operations at the date on which it ceases to be used. In considering whether the operations of WiConnect have “ceased to be used” management considered that as at year-end, and for some time prior, WiConnect’s retail stores had ceased trading (even during the periods of the national lockdown where trading was permissible). Furthermore, all inventory had been transferred to a central warehouse, cash collected and transferred from stores, and affected staff informed of their retrenchment. Additionally, all landlords to the WiConnect retail stores were also informed prior to year-end of the intention to cease all operations. Therefore, while there were still run-off costs to be incurred and assets to be sold and scrapped, these were elements of the closing down of the WiConnect operations. Based on this, together with the fact that inventory had been written down to its net realisable value and sold to one buyer, it was management’s contention that the operations were not ongoing and that the inflows and outflows which were still to occur did not comprise an activity. Based on these facts and circumstances, management applied its judgement and concluded that the operations of WiConnect had “ceased to be used”. Management believes that this assessment is still applicable.
Management applied further significant judgement in determining whether the operations of WiConnect met the discontinued operations criteria as at 31 May 2020. More specifically, management needed to consider whether WiConnect may have been classified as a separate major line of business. Under IFRS 8, reportable segments could comprise more than one business segment. Therefore, the fact that WiConnect does not form its own reportable segment (it is included in the Africa Distribution segment) did not preclude it from being considered a major line of business. Executive management and chief operating decision-makers considered WiConnect to be a separate major line of business as a result of several considerations, namely that it was brick-and-mortar retail (or physical stores owned and operated by the Group) directly interacting with customers in the retail space through our own channels/stores selling hardware and other value-added services directly to consumers. This, coupled with the loss after tax of R318 million (which is considered to be material in the context of the overall Group results for the year ended 31 May 2020), led to management applying its judgement in concluding that WiConnect was a separate major line of business and consequently met the definition of a discontinued operation. Management believes that this assessment is still applicable.
6. Borrowings
Borrowings are recognised initially at fair value, net of transaction costs incurred, when the relevant contracts are entered into. Borrowings are subsequently stated at amortised cost; any difference between the proceeds (net of transaction costs) and the redemption value is recognised in the income statement over the period of the borrowings using the effective interest rate method.
Financial liabilities are derecognised when the obligation specified in the contract is discharged, cancelled or expired.
Borrowings are classified as current liabilities unless the Group has an unconditional right to defer settlement of the liability for at least 12 months after period end.
30 November 2021 Unaudited R'000 |
31 May 2021 Audited R'000 |
||
Interest-bearing borrowings | 1 968 633 | 1 706 163 | |
---|---|---|---|
Non-interest-bearing borrowings | 719 | 989 | |
1 969 352 | 1 707 152 | ||
Less: Amounts included in current portion of borrowings | (1 834 282) | (1 704 374) | |
Non-current portion of borrowings | 135 070 | 2 778 |
The table below details the facilities drawn upon at 30 November 2021.
Facility utilised | |||||
Facility | Investec | Africa Bank |
30 November 2021 Unaudited R'000 |
31 May 2021 Audited R'000 |
|
Mezzanine facility | 100% | — | — | 410 532 | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Facility A | 100% | — | 1 465 851 | 1 292 637 | |
Africa Bank* | — | 100% | 500 000 | — | |
1 965 851 | 1 703 169 |
* | CEC has access to a total facility of R1.9 billion with Africa Bank, of which R500 million was drawn down as at 30 November 2021. The security provided on the R500 million comprised the outstanding value of handset receivables totalling R1.35 billion and a parent guarantee of R250 million provided by BLT. Interest is charged at 11.05% fixed and the borrowing is repayable over 24 months. |
The Group did not default on any loans or breach any terms of the underlying agreements during the period.
Changes in liabilities arising from financing activities
Borrowings due within one year R'000 |
Borrowings due after one year R'000 |
Total R'000 |
||
Opening balance - 1 June 2020 | 2 316 383 | 2 778 | 2 319 161 | |
Acquisition of subsidiary | 726 | — | 726 | |
Non-interest-bearing borrowings raised | 270 | — | 270 | |
Non-interest-bearing borrowings repaid | (13 959) | — | (13 959) | |
Interest-bearing borrowings repaid | (751 053) | — | (751 053) | |
Interest-bearing borrowings raised | 152 007 | — | 152 007 | |
Closing balance - 31 May 2021 | 1 704 374 | 2 778 | 1 707 152 | |
Interest-bearing-borrowings raised through the acquisition of non-controlling interest (refer to note 7) | 104 950 | — | 104 950 | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Non-interest-bearing borrowings repaid | (270) | — | (270) | |
Interest-bearing borrowings repaid | (368 155) | — | (368 155) | |
Interest-bearing borrowings raised | 393 383 | 132 292 | 525 675 | |
Closing balance - 30 November 2021 | 1 834 282 | 135 070 | 1 969 352 |
7. Financial guarantee contracts
Financial guarantee contracts are recognised at fair value on the date that the Group becomes a party to an irrevocable commitment. Financial guarantee contracts are subsequently stated at the higher of the amount determined by the expected credit loss (ECL) model and the amount initially recognised. Any difference between the redemption value guarantee obligation and the amount paid is recognised in the income statement.
30 November 2021 Unaudited R'000 |
31 May 2021 Audited R'000 |
||
Opening balance | 105 621 | 201 474 | |
---|---|---|---|
Foreign exchange movement | — | (9 113) | |
Used during the year | — | (53 285) | |
Extinguishment of guarantee contract through the acquisition of non-controlling interest* | (104 950) | — | |
Amounts released through profit or loss - continuing operations | — | (33 455) | |
Closing carrying amount | 671 | 105 621 | |
Less: Amounts included in non-current portion of financial guarantee contracts | — | — | |
671 | 105 621 |
* | On 29 June 2021, The Prepaid Company Proprietary Limited (TPC) acquired the remaining 52% shareholding in Glocell Distribution Proprietary Limited (Glocell). As part of the purchase arrangement, TPC assumed Glocell's obligation of R105 million to Investec Bank Limited. Refer to note 6. |
The Group has not raised a liability for its guarantee to the consortium of financial institutions in respect of Cell C's funding of R30.6 million (May 2021: R182 million) due to the fact that it holds sufficient collateral, which the Group expects to realise should the guarantee be called upon and the residual financial risk not be material.
8. Financial instruments
Substantially all financial instruments at fair value through profit or loss are classified as level 3 instruments in the fair value hierarchy. Changes in instruments are as follows:
Loans receivable R'000 |
Derivative liability R'000 |
Surety loan receivable R'000 |
Other R'000 |
Total R'000 |
||
Opening balance as at 1 June 2021 | 126 604 | (68 178) | 83 713 | 8 258 | 150 397 | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Additions | 49 524 | — | — | 750 | 50 274 | |
Repayments | — | — | — | (7 875) | (7 875) | |
Conversion to equity | (126 604) | — | — | — | (126 604) | |
Fair value gains recognised in profit or loss | 133 | — | — | 563 | 696 | |
Closing balance as at 30 November 2021 | 49 657 | (68 178) | 83 713 | 1 696 | 66 888 | |
Financial assets at fair value through profit or loss | 49 657 | — | 83 713 | 1 696 | 135 066 | |
Current | 8 163 | — | 8 371 | 1 696 | 18 230 | |
Non-current | 41 494 | — | 75 342 | — | 116 836 | |
Financial liabilities at fair value through profit or loss | — | (68 178) | — | — | (68 178) | |
Current | — | (68 178) | — | — | (68 178) | |
Non-current | — | — | — | — | — | |
Loans at fair value
The Prepaid Company Proprietary Limited (TPC) acquired a 48% share in Glocell Distribution Proprietary Limited (Glocell Distribution) on 30 June 2018.
In terms of an agreement entered into between TPC and Glocell Proprietary Limited (Glocell) during the year ended 31 May 2019, Glocell pledged its 40% shareholding in Glocell Distribution to TPC in the event of Glocell defaulting on amounts owing to TPC.
On 29 June 2021, TPC acquired the remaining 52% shareholding in Glocell Distribution for a total purchase consideration of R137 million, of which R126 million was discharged by way of a conversion of the loan at fair value owing by Glocell to TPC.
As part of the fraud recoupment (refer note 11), the Group acquired the right to a loan made to a third party. The loan is for R73 million, bears interest at prime (30 November 2021: 7.25%) and is repayable in full by 30 June 2026. Only interest is payable up to 30 June 2022 and thereafter interest and capital are payable. In addition to the interest payments required, the borrower has the right to pay R10 million capital by 1 July 2022 in return for a R14 million reduction (i.e. a R4 million discount) in the capital amount of the loan. It is the Group's view that this term results in the contractual cash flows failing to meet the requirements for amortised cost accounting, causing the right to the loan to be measured at fair value through profit or loss. The fair value of the right to the loan reflects a market-related interest rate of prime plus 5% and credit risk-adjusted expected cash flows.
Derivative liability
This relates to the put options for the acquisition of a 40% minority interest in Airvantage and AV Technology. There have been no changes to the facts and circumstances related to the liability for the six months ended 30 November 2021. Refer to note 12 for details on the amendment to the terms of this agreement.
Surety loans receivable
Surety loans relate to the personal sureties that B Levy and M Levy signed for the loan owed by 2DFine Holdings Mauritius to Gold Label Investments Proprietary Limited. Their liability is limited to the difference between the loan owing to Gold Label Investments Proprietary Limited and the value of 16.95% of the shares in Oxigen Services India Private Limited (Oxigen Services) and 17.29% of the shares in Oxigen Online Services India Private Limited (Oxigen Online). In the 2020 financial year the payment terms for the surety loans were renegotiated, with the payments being agreed as instalments payable annually commencing on 30 September 2021 and ending on 30 September 2030.
9. Significant related party transactions and balances
Six months ended 30 November 2021 Unaudited R'000 |
Six months ended 30 November 2020 Unaudited R'000 |
Year ended 31 May 2021 Audited R'000 |
||
Sales to related parties | ||||
T3 Telecoms SA Proprietary Limited* | 2 054 917 | 1 469 472 | 3 394 108 | |
Cell C Proprietary Limited* | 1 047 730 | 1 015 039 | 1 729 573 | |
I Talk Holdings Proprietary Limited* | 11 774 | 12 661 | 23 756 | |
Purchases from related parties | ||||
Cell C Proprietary Limited* | 2 483 678 | 1 400 244 | 4 275 098 | |
T3 Telecoms SA Proprietary Limited* | 6 760 | — | 14 154 | |
I Talk Holdings Proprietary Limited* | 8 164 | 14 194 | 12 935 | |
Finance revenue received from related parties | ||||
Cell C Proprietary Limited* | 47 426 | 48 237 | 95 951 | |
Dividends received from related parties | ||||
I Talk Holdings Proprietary Limited* | — | 14 000 | 5 000 | |
Loans to related parties | ||||
2DFine Holdings Mauritius*# | 214 674 | 218 879 | 196 513 | |
2DFine Investments Mauritius*# | 3 943 | 3 700 | 3 318 | |
Brett Levy | 41 857 | 46 283 | 45 908 | |
Mark Levy | 41 857 | 46 283 | 41 857 | |
Oxigen Services India Private Limited*# | 54 105 | 50 658 | 41 857 | |
T3 Telecoms SA Proprietary Limited* | 14 735 | 8 254 | 15 016 | |
I Talk Holdings Proprietary Limited* | 21 900 | 2 000 | 2 000 | |
Total loss allowance on loans to related parties | (275 478) | (274 673) | (247 992) | |
Lease liability due to related parties | ||||
Ellerine Bros. Proprietary Limited | 14 343 | 21 943 | 18 419 | |
Moneyline 311 Proprietary Limited | 14 343 | 21 943 | 18 419 | |
Uvongo Falls No 26 Proprietary Limited | 14 723 | 23 048 | 18 859 | |
Amounts due from related parties included in trade receivables | ||||
Cell C Proprietary Limited* | 2 122 181 | 1 510 876 | 1 677 193 | |
Total loss allowance on trade receivables to related parties | (10 263) | (8 801) | (10 931) | |
Amounts due to related parties included in trade payables | ||||
Cell C Proprietary Limited* | 767 353 | 69 175 | 456 902 |
* | These entities are associates/joint ventures. |
# | These loans have been fully provided for both in the current and prior years and are included as part of the total loss allowance on loans to related parties balance. |
10. Cell C Limited
On 2 August 2017, Blue Label, through its wholly owned subsidiary, The Prepaid Company Proprietary Limited (TPC) acquired 45% of the issued share capital of Cell C Limited (Cell C) for a purchase consideration of R5.5 billion.
As at 31 May 2019, the Group's investment in Cell C was impaired to nil. It remains at nil as at 30 November 2021.
Critical accounting judgements and assumptions
Going concern of Cell C
For purposes of the Group's interim financial statements for the half-year ended 30 November 2021, Cell C has been accounted for using the going concern assumption. As the Group's share of Cell C's losses exceed the carrying amount of the investment (Rnil), the Group has ceased recognising its share of further losses. If Cell C subsequently generates profits, the Group will resume recognising its share of profits only after its share of the profits equals the share of losses not recognised.
Based on the following facts available, management is of the opinion that Cell C will continue as a going concern for the foreseeable future:
- Cell C concluded the national roaming agreement with MTN on 7 August 2019, which became effective on 4 May 2020. This agreement is one of the key pillars in Cell C's transformation plan as well as its long-term network strategy to optimise operating costs and reduce capital outlay as part of the turnaround strategy. This agreement is anticipated to positively impact the cost base and future cash flows on the successful implementation of this transaction.
- The board of Cell C established a liquidity committee to monitor the liquidity position of Cell C and to ensure that the business is not trading recklessly during the negotiations of the recapitalisation and debt restructure. Although the liquidity position of Cell C remains challenging, Cell C has proven that it has managed to continue trading despite the liquidity concerns and management is confident that this committee will manage the liquidity position of Cell C until the conclusion of the recapitalisation process.
- Cell C appointed independent financial restructuring advisers to assist in stringent monitoring of the liquidity of Cell C as well as designing the revised business plans that support the new operating business model.
- Management remains optimistic that the planned recapitalisation of Cell C will be successful. The recapitalisation is important to improve the capital structure of the Company and the deferral of repayments that will support the long-term sustainability of Cell C. Stakeholders have appointed independent advisers to assist with the recapitalisation and/or debt restructuring process and formal engagements are ongoing.
- A roaming agreement with Vodacom was concluded in November 2020 which is aligned to Cell C's revised network strategy, aimed at managing capacity in a more scalable and cost-efficient manner through a roaming model. Contract and broadband customers will be transitioned in stages to roam on the Vodacom network. The strategic vision is to differentiate Cell C by focusing on innovative products and services without being owners of capital intensive infrastructure. This creates more flexibility and capacity to deliver the right quality of service to our current and future customers.
- Cell C embarked on a strategy to reconsider its current service offering, whereby Cell C identified the need to either wind down or restructure the service offering being provided to its postpaid mobile telecommunication business (the base). During the 2021 financial year, the Group, through its subsidiary CEC, entered into an arrangement with Cell C to facilitate Cell C's operation of the base. The agreement commenced on 1 November 2020 for an initial period of five years, with CEC having the right to renew for a further four years. CEC is entitled to receive a share of the subscription income generated by Cell C from a subset of postpaid subscribers that sign up, extend or upgrade their subscriptions with Cell C after 1 November 2020 (New and Upgrade subscribers) plus certain fixed and variable payments. Cell C will remain entitled to the subscription income of existing subscribers at 31 October 2020 for the remainder of the subscribers' contract and a share of the ongoing revenue of New and Upgrade subscribers. The aim of the reorganisation would be for the base to remain intact and grow in the future, and for Cell C to have limited downside risk on the base.
On 4 August 2020, Cell C notified its noteholders that it defaulted on the payment of capital on its USD184 002 000 note which was due on 2 August 2020, as well as interest and capital repayments related to the respective bilateral loan facilities between Cell C and Nedbank Limited, China Development Bank Corporation, Development Bank of Southern Africa Limited and Industrial and Commercial Bank of China Limited, which were due in January and July 2020.
Currently, none of the bilateral loan facilities have been accelerated as noteholders are aware and support that Cell C is committed to resolving the situation by agreeing to restructuring terms with its lenders while it also continues to work proactively with all stakeholders to improve its liquidity, debt profile and long-term competitiveness.
Management and the directors have taken the default into consideration as part of their overall assessment of the going concern principle for Cell C and are of the view that the going concern assumption is still applicable. The default does not change any judgements or assumptions made in the financial assumptions that are dependent on the continuing operation of Cell C as a going concern.
On 26 August 2021, TPC concluded a term sheet for an Airtime Purchase transaction with Investec Bank Limited, First Rand Bank Limited (acting through its Rand Merchant Bank division) and other financiers, the proceeds of which are intended to be utilised for the recapitalisation of Cell C. This arrangement was subject to the conclusion of all legal documentation and fulfilment of all conditions precedent under such legal documentation.
Although no certainty exists around the successful implementation of the recapitalisation, management remains optimistic.
Classification of Cell C Limited as an associate
The Group will be entitled to appoint four of the 11 directors to the Cell C Board which will represent 36% of the overall votes of the Board. Based on the Group's shareholding and representation on the Board, management has assessed Cell C Limited to be an associate, as the Group will have the power to participate in (but not control) the financial and operating policy decisions of Cell C Limited.
Impairment of Cell C
TPC's share of the value-in-use of Cell C as at 30 November 2021 remained at nil value. The valuation was performed in order to determine the value-in-use of Cell C based on cash flow projections incorporated in its five-year business plan. Assumptions that were applied by Cell C relate to the business, the industry and economic growth. Cash flows beyond this point were then extrapolated, applying a terminal growth rate. The valuation does not take into account the effects of any planned future restructuring or recapitalisation.
Summarised financial information
Principal activity: Mobile network
Country of incorporation: South Africa
Financial year-end*: 31 December
30 November 2021 R'000 |
31 May 2021 R'000 |
||
Statement of financial position | |||
Non-current assets | 13 693 399 | 13 565 997 | |
Current assets | 7 466 021 | 6 228 984 | |
21 159 420 | 19 794 981 | ||
Total equity | (6 392 031) | (5 559 338) | |
Non-current liabilities | 5 636 332 | 5 800 315 | |
Current liabilities | 21 915 119 | 19 554 004 | |
21 159 420 | 19 794 981 | ||
Effective percentage held (%) | 45 | 45 | |
Net assets | (6 392 031) | (5 559 338) | |
Company net assets | (13 691 961) | (12 859 268) | |
Carrying value of purchase price allocations net of deferred taxation | 7 299 930 | 7 299 930 | |
Interest in associate | (2 876 414) | (2 501 702) | |
Goodwill | 1 317 776 | 1 317 776 | |
Accumulated impairment | (2 521 152) | (2 521 152) | |
Accumulated losses not guaranteed | 4 079 790 | 3 705 078 | |
Balance at the end of the period | — | — |
Statement of comprehensive income for the six months ended
30 November 2021 R'000 |
30 November 2020 R'000 |
|||
Revenue | 6 679 641 | 7 121 155 | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Net (loss)/profit before taxation | (832 694) | 1 217 679 | ||
Taxation | — | — | ||
Net (loss)/profit after taxation | (832 694) | 1 217 679 | ||
Other comprehensive income | — | — | ||
Losses not guaranteed/(profits not recognised)** | 832 694 | (1 217 679) | ||
Total comprehensive income | — | — | ||
Effective percentage held | 45 | 45 | ||
Share of total comprehensive income | — | — |
* | Where the financial half-year-end differs from the Group's half-year-end of 30 November, special purpose accounts are prepared to coincide with the Group's reporting period. |
** | The Group will resume recognising its share of the profits only after its share of the profits equals the share of accumulated losses not recognised. |
Financial guarantee in respect of Cell C’s facility
On 2 August 2018, Cell C procured R1.4 billion of funding from a consortium of financial institutions for a tenure of 12 months, secured by airtime to the value of R1.75 billion. In the event of default, TPC could have been required by the consortium to purchase such inventory from the consortium on a piecemeal basis over a specified period that has been agreed upon. These purchases would be made in lieu of purchases that would have been made from Cell C within that period.
An extension was concluded on 31 May 2020 with an agreed quantum of airtime purchases required to be made by TPC on a monthly basis. This would have resulted in the Cell C facility reducing to nil by 31 March 2021. As at 30 November 2021, the above funding had declined to R31 million (May 2021: R182 million) as a result of TPC purchasing from the security airtime.
It is the intention of TPC to accelerate payments to the banking consortium in order to distribute the vault stock in full if there is risk/indication that Cell C will not be able to meet its obligations to the banking consortium. The fair value of the financial guarantee issued in respect of Cell C’s facility was valued to be insignificant, taking into account the inventory held as collateral.
Management has performed detailed assessments considering seasonality of trading and has determined that, based on current inventory holdings and anticipated sales cycles, should circumstances dictate the need to purchase the above mentioned inventory from the consortium, acceleration of such payments could well result in the debt being expunged within two and a half months through its trading capabilities in the ordinary course of business at normal operating margins.
11. Fraud recoupment
The Group uncovered a fraudulent scheme, operating since 2015, which was perpetrated by two former senior key executives (“the perpetrators”) of a subsidiary company (“the subsidiary”). These fraudulent transactions were performed primarily outside the course and scope of the subsidiary’s immediate field of commercial dealings, whereby the perpetrators interposed themselves between intermediary companies and the subsidiary for their own benefit. In addition, certain transactions were identified evidencing theft of funds from the subsidiary and the fraudulent concealment thereof. Settlement agreements were signed with the perpetrators in late October 2021, in terms of which rights to all, but a few, assets of the perpetrators were signed-over to the Group. The Group holds Powers of Attorney over these assets. As of 31 October 2021, the aggregate value of assets either realised by or signed-over to the Group as a result of the fraudulent scheme, amounted to R315 million, which has been recognised as recoupment income within other income, and comprised the following:
R’000 | ||
Rights to: | ||
Immovable property | 42 2951 | |
Loans made to third parties | 63 1242 | |
Unlisted shares | 13 1003 | |
Listed share portfolio | 7504 | |
Bank accounts | 191 5275 | |
Inventory | 448 | |
Other | 4 240 | |
315 484 |
1 | Rights to immovable property have been accounted for as rights to receive non-current assets and were recognised initially at their fair value using comparable market prices. As it is not the intention of the Group to acquire legal title to the properties or to keep the rights for the long term, the Group is actively marketing these properties and expects to realise them all within the next 12 months. Accordingly, the rights to receive immovable property have been classified as non-current assets held-for-sale and are presented as such under current assets on the statement of financial position. These rights are measured at the lower of the initial amount recognised and fair value less costs to sell. Since the perpetrators are required to bear the costs to sell, these have been assumed to be zero for the Group’s measurement purposes. Properties to the value of R8.5 million were sold by 30 November 2021, resulting in the derecognition of the related right and the recognition of a receivable for the sale proceeds which are expected to be received within the next 12 months. |
2 | The right to a loan made to a third party with a carrying amount of R49.5 million has been accounted for as a financial asset at fair value through profit or loss. Early prepayment features resulted in the underlying loan failing the requirements for amortised cost accounting. Refer to note 8. The rights to the remaining loans receivable have been measured at amortised cost. |
3 | At about the time of the settlement agreement, an agreement was reached for the sale of certain unlisted shares owned by the perpetrators, the proceeds of which are payable to the Group within the next few months. Accordingly, the Group recognised a receivable for such proceeds, measured initially at fair value, which is subject to the Group’s accounting policy for expected credit losses. |
4 | The right to the listed share portfolio has been accounted for as a financial asset at fair value through profit or loss based on quoted share prices. |
5 | Substantially all funds that were found to be held in bank accounts have been transferred to the Group’s bank accounts. |
Professional fees incurred relating to the fraud recoupment amounted to R36 million to the end of November 2021 and have been included in other expenses.
Subsequent to the fraud investigation and detailed review of the control environment and business processes within the subsidiary, management has implemented the necessary improvements relating to the existing control environment.
12. Subsequent events
Banking facilities
In February 2022, The Prepaid Company Proprietary Limited renegotiated a further extension of its Investec facility to 31 March 2023. The total facility amounting to R1.56 billion outstanding as at 30 November 2021 was reduced by R340 million to R1.22 billion to date. Thereafter, the exposure to Investec is required to be reduced by a further R30 million per month in order to reduce the maximum facility balance to R1.01 billion.
Airvantage and AV Technology put obligations
On 14 December 2021 Blue Label Telecoms Limited (BLT) concluded agreements with the 40% shareholders of each of AV Technologies Limited (Mauritius) and Airvantage Proprietary Limited (South Africa) in terms of which the put options which such vendors had against BLT were terminated. On 15 December 2021 BLT concluded a put option agreement with Digital Ecosystems Proprietary Limited (formerly Blue Label Mobile Group) in terms of which Digital Ecosystems acquired the right to put up to 40% of the shares in Airvantage Proprietary Limited (South Africa) to BLT no earlier than 15 December 2022 for a maximum amount of R110 million. If Cell C Limited, through a board resolution, passes a solvency and liquidity test prior to 15 December 2022, the put option will be terminated.
13. Basis of preparation
The condensed unaudited consolidated interim financial statements are prepared in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards, IAS 34 –Interim Financial Reporting, the SAICA Financial Reporting Guides as issued by the Accounting Practices Committee and Financial Pronouncements as issued by Financial Reporting Standards Council and the requirements of the Companies Act of South Africa. The accounting policies applied in the preparation of these interim financial statements are in terms of International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) and are consistent with those applied in the previous annual financial statements.
We aim to provide stakeholders with the same additional information that management uses to evaluate the performance of the Group’s operations. Accordingly, we make reference to operating profit before depreciation, amortisation and impairment charges (EBITDA). In addition, the Group applies core net profit and core headline earnings as non-IFRS measures in evaluating the Group’s performance. This supplements the IFRS measures. Core net profit is calculated by adjusting net profit for the year with the amortisation of intangible assets that arise as a consequence of the purchase price allocations completed in terms of IFRS 3(R) – Business Combinations. Core headline earnings are calculated by adjusting core net profit with the headline earnings adjustments required by SAICA Circular 4/2018.
The results for the period ended 30 November 2021 have not been reviewed or audited.